Jul 19 2010
Homemade Yogurt
I never would have predicted that having a baby would bring out the cook in me. Granted, my hubby and I have long loved trying new flavors, cooking together, testing new recipes. But the fact that I’m doing most of the cooking now as a stay-at-home mom, our smaller budget since becoming a one-income family, and my recent commitment to buy local whenever possible, I’ve gone gang-buster for making-from-scratch foods I would have typically bought at the grocery store.
I’m using Super Baby Food as one of my resources as I plan to make as much of my son’s food as possible. And because the hubby and I eat so much yogurt, I thought I’d try that well in advance of when baby is eating yogurt, so I can get the hang of it.

In the last week we’ve made 6 quart-size batches of yogurt - 3 have failed (although we’ve used that tangy milk for smoothies), but we’ve been enjoying our 3 successful quarts.
The How…
(there are many recipes online)

- First, we scalded the milk to 185 degrees Farenheit
- Then, we let the milk cool to approximately 115 degrees Farenheit (the milk needs to remain between 90-120 degrees in order for the yogurt cultures to survive)
- Once cooled, we mixed in 2 Tablespoons of plain yogurt with live active cultures (using plain Stoneyfield Farm yogurt for the first batch - no we can use the yogurt we made as a “starter”)
- After covering the jars, we’ve tried a few different methods for incubating the yogurt, which takes many hours. The option that has worked for us is keeping the jars of yogurt-in-the-making in a water bath on the stove on the lowest temperature. Every hour or so we’ll move the yogurt off the heat so the temperature doesn’t rise too much.
- After 4-14 hours (the longer you incubate, the tangier the yogurt), refrigerate to thicken the yogurt further and voila! Homemade Yogurt!

Afterthoughts…
This (and many others from our perspective) method does require some baby-sitting, so it’s best to do when you plan to be home most of the day. If we find we are making alot of yogurt I may invest in a yogurt-maker.
For us, whole milk came out the thickest and creamiest not surprisingly, but we also had a batch of 2% milk work. To make the resulting yogurt thicker, we strained the whey out through cheesecloth to achieve the desired texture.


The cost breakdown…
I generally buy either individual servings of organic Stonyfield Farm yogurt for $.99 a pop, or the quart size occasionally for $3.99.
Our yogurt (using organic milk for $3.69/half gallon) costs about $1.50/quart. Definitely a cost savings that’s worth it!


























